Did man ever really walk on the moon?
The perils of limited perspective
Short answer, yes. After all these years, expeditions to space and major scientific discoveries, I can say with absolute certainty that man has walked on the moon.
But to me, the real question is: Was it done when we claim it was?
Two weeks ago, I would have said, “Obviously! Of course we have walked on the moon! Do you really think that the United States could pull off such an elaborate lie for no reason? Anybody who says it’s even possible that we didn’t walk on the moon is totally ignorant!”
Then, last week, I did some research and watched a short documentary about the controversy, just to see what the other side was talking about.
Throughout my research, I saw many very interesting facts and events that, put together, form a strong argument that the United States lied about going to the moon in 1969.
For instance, the United States was in the middle of the Cold War with the Soviet Union, the first nation to successfully send people to outer space, and we didn’t want to let them ‘beat us’ in the race to the moon. The motive seemed simple enough.
Next, with all of Hollywood’s technology, green screens, computers and video editing, I guess it is possible (yet improbable), that the moon landing could have been faked. Finally, there was a good amount of evidence — circumstantial, of course, yet very convincing — such as the footage of a flag waving on the moon, even though there is no wind in space to make it move.
Overall, the evidence for the moon landing that I came across in my research seemed simple enough, and, to tell you the truth, I’m still not sure I believe in the conspiracy. However, I do know that this documentary changed the way I see things.
I had such blind faith that the moon landing in ‘69 happened; it was easy to accept what I had always felt was fact, with the vast majority holding the same belief, and ridiculing the minority as conspiracy theorists. I honestly believed that people who doubted its truth were totally ignorant. I now see that I could not have been more wrong.
It was really me who was being ignorant, making an assumption with no research to back it. I had no right to make such claims, especially judgments about people with different perspectives, without knowing all the facts and seeing both sides. Now more than ever before, it’s absolutely integral that we put aside any pre-existing biases or assumptions and take the time to educate ourselves, especially before we start speaking about a topic.
This really made me think, and led me to the worst realization of them all: it’s not just me making these assumptions.
In today’s day and age, with so many different studies and people making such different claims, it is difficult to make informed decisions. With so much controversy surrounding every topic, even those who research before coming to any conclusions can often be wrong.
However, it is integral that we do try to separate fact from fiction. Put yourself in another’s shoes, try to see why they have the views that they do. Analyze multiple studies with potentially different conclusions, and talk to different people (respectfully) to try to see the full picture and help educate one another.
The flag was waving, the shadows aren’t right, the reflection was suspicious – all of these are arguments that many take in debating the veracity of the moon landing. So before you can even begin to argue against these ideas, try for a moment to play devil’s advocate. You may find yourself adopting a new belief system, or, if your mind remains unchanged, you mind find an argument there. Who knows, it’s worth a try, right?
With so many people finding “fake news,” and losing faith in each other and the press, it is essential that we think before we speak, and even more important that we Google before we can begin to believe.
Your donation will support the student journalists of Oak Park High School - CA. Your contribution will allow us to purchase equipment and cover our annual website hosting costs.
Jay Dugar is a senior at Oak Park High School and Managing Editor for the 2020-21 school year. He served as Managing Editor between 2018-20 and a staff...